Episode 2: One Dwelling From Murder
Serial Killer that lived in each of the towns Jenna has.
Episode 3: One Disaster From Murder
Adam Lack, high school friend of host, Kelly
Episodes 4 and 5 - removed for the time being
Episode 6: One Darold From Murder
The story of Darold Stenson who murdered his associate and wife
Episode 7: One Disparagement From Murder
The story of Louise Thoreson's murder of her millionaire, gun-loving husband, William Thoreson
Episode 8: One Devil From Murder
The story of Jennifer and Abby Blagg
Episode 9: One Delusion From Murder
Jenna discusses a listener-submitted story of Nate Fox's murder by a stranger with a delusion.
S1, E10: One Destination From Murder
The story of Lisa Marie Kimmell, known as Lil' Miss
Episode 11: One Disappearance From Murder
The disappearance of Amy Wroe Bechtel in Lander, Wyoming
Episode 12: One Divorce From Murder
Jenna discusses the twists of Drew Peterson's life and the disappearance of Stacy Peterson
Episode 13: One Divination From Murder
Kelly discusses a listener submission of an unsolved double murder of a mother and child in Omaha Nebraska.